How to Avoid Costly ERP Implementation Pitfalls: The Power of ERP Selection & Requirements Gathering specifically for Manufacturing companies

April 25, 2025

GP Manufacturing to BC Analysis

When embarking on an ERP project, especially in the manufacturing space, success hinges on thorough ERP selection and detailed requirements gathering. In this blog post, we explore a real-world scenario involving Microsoft Dynamics GP and Business Central to highlight why running a comprehensive requirements analysis is essential before making any platform decision.

How to Avoid Costly ERP Implementation Pitfalls: The Power of ERP Selection & Requirements Gathering specifically for Manufacturing companies

The ERP Implementation Dilemma

Imagine a manufacturing company that recently transitioned from Microsoft Dynamics GP (Great Plains) to Business Central (BC). At a user group meeting, a customer shared that their new BC implementation wasn’t delivering the expected results. Despite a full sales process that included input from partners and sales teams, there was a lingering uncertainty about whether the chosen ERP would truly meet their unique operational needs.

The Critical Role of Requirements Gathering

In our conversation with the customer, we discovered that their specific type of manufacturing operations posed a significant challenge for BC. While the initial analysis suggested a 60% fit between BC and their core business requirements, further examination revealed the following:


  • Finance vs. Manufacturing Fit:
    The finance module showed only about a 10% difference in requirements alignment, indicating that finance was not the issue. Instead, the manufacturing specifics created the real challenge.

  • Manufacturing Module Disparity:
    When drilling down into the manufacturing requirements, the disparity widened dramatically. BC only achieved a 60% fit, whereas an alternative system (F&SCM) offered up to a 98% fit. That 40% gap in manufacturing capabilities could mean the difference between having an ideal system that drives competitive advantage and relying on workarounds like spreadsheets or third-party integrations.


GP Manufacturing to BC Analysis

Why ERP Selection Matters

The key takeaway for any manufacturing company—especially those using Great Plains—is to invest time in robust requirements gathering before finalizing an ERP selection. By using an online requirements analysis tool, companies can:


  • Identify Critical Gaps:
    Understand the exact areas where a proposed ERP system falls short.

  • Prevent Future Disappointment:
    Avoid costly, time-consuming implementations that fail to meet operational needs.

  • Optimize ROI:
    Ensure that the chosen ERP system not only supports current processes but also scales with future business growth.

A Call to Action for Manufacturing Leaders

Before committing to an ERP platform like Microsoft Dynamics Business Central, ask yourself: Have you thoroughly analyzed your core business requirements? An upfront, detailed evaluation of your manufacturing needs can save you a lot of time, money, and heartache in the long run.


Key Takeaways:


  • ERP Selection: Choose the right system by carefully analyzing how each ERP solution aligns with your business requirements.

  • Requirements Gathering: Leverage tools and expert analysis to pinpoint exactly what your manufacturing operation needs from an ERP solution.

  • Avoid Implementation Pitfalls: A proper evaluation process can prevent project failure and ensure your ERP investment drives true competitive advantage.



By prioritizing ERP selection and comprehensive requirements gathering, you position your manufacturing company for a successful ERP implementation that truly supports your business objectives.


Investing in the right approach today means avoiding costly mistakes tomorrow. Take the time to do the analysis first, then decide your direction—your operational efficiency and profitability depend on it.

HandsFree ERP is dedicated to supporting clients with their ERP initiatives, enabling companies to seamlessly connect users with their ERP partners. By utilizing skilled professionals, streamlined processes, and cutting-edge tools, HandsFree ERP significantly boosts the success rates of ERP projects.

By Peter Joeckel September 11, 2025
Most organizations think data migration is about moving records from A to B. They're wrong. It's about transforming business information into operational truth. Get it wrong, and you're just digitizing your problems at enterprise scale. If you’re a distributor or manufacturer, your business runs on inventory. Simple as that. Everything else, sales, purchasing, operations, revolves around making sure your inventory data is accurate. And yet, so many companies struggle with messy, outdated, or outright incorrect data, setting themselves up for major headaches when it comes time to implement or upgrade an ERP system. For manufacturers and distributors, inventory is the heart of the business. Everything revolves around managing it effectively. In ERP terms, this involves three core processes: 1. Procure-to-Pay – Bringing inventory in from suppliers. 2. Manufacturing or Handling – Transforming or repackaging inventory. 3. Order-to-Cash – Shipping inventory out to customers. At the heart of the problem are three core data sets: customers, suppliers, and inventory . Clean and accurate data here isn’t optional. It’s essential. Let me paint you a picture of what poor data quality really costs: - Financial processes failing because customer master data is inconsistent - Supply chain grinding to a halt because item masters don't match across systems - Month-end closing taking weeks because nobody trusts the numbers - Compliance risks because audit trails are incomplete or incorrect I've seen implementations declare success after migrating millions of records, only to discover they've built a perfect system running on garbage data. The result? Unreliable reporting, broken processes, and users creating shadow systems to track "real" data. Here's what your implementation partner isn't telling you: Data quality issues compound over time. Every day you operate with poor data, you're creating new problems that will need to be fixed later. It's like trying to build a skyscraper on quicksand - no matter how perfect your architecture, IT IS GOING TO SINK. The hard truth: No amount of system optimization can fix bad data. You're either managing data quality now, or you're managing data problems forever. And in D365 F&O, forever gets expensive very quickly. Bills of Materials: The Science That Trips Everyone Up For manufacturers, one of the biggest trouble spots is the Bill of Materials (BOM) . Think of the BOM as a recipe: it defines exactly how components come together to make a finished product, like a “little red wagon.” Each part must be accounted for, structured correctly, and contain only inventory items. Here’s where things go wrong: Many BOMs have too many levels or include non-inventory items like labor and overhead. Legacy systems often force companies to create Frankenstein part numbers that are confusing and error-prone. Process manufacturers with “recipes” face additional complexity because ingredient quality can fluctuate, affecting output consistency. Moving this messy data into a modern ERP without cleaning it first can turn your new system into a nightmare rather than an improvement. Routing: Where Art Meets Science Beyond the BOM, there’s routing , the step-by-step instructions for manufacturing a product. Routing data is critical for understanding capacity, scheduling, and cost management. Capturing work center setup times, labor, material, and overhead costs is key. Most companies simply don’t have this data organized, which means ERP projects often start off on the wrong foot. Planning Ahead: The Key to ERP Success Waiting until the ERP project is live to clean and organize your data is a recipe for disaster. By then, your best engineers and data experts are fully occupied, leaving little time to fix deep-rooted issues. Forward-thinking manufacturers and distributors start data workshops well before the ERP implementation . These workshops: Identify issues in customer, supplier, and inventory data Clean and structure BOMs and routings properly Establish proper part numbering and chart of accounts setups Doing this ahead of time dramatically increases the chances of a smooth, successful ERP deployment—regardless of which system you choose. Bottom line: messy data doesn’t just slow you down, it can completely derail your ERP implementation. Start early, clean it up, and structure it correctly. Your future self (and your new ERP system) will thank you. 
By Kati Hvidtfeldt September 5, 2025
Data Migration is #1 reason for Go-Live Delays
By Kati Hvidtfeldt August 6, 2025
Importance of Data Health Assessment
By Kati Hvidtfeldt July 25, 2025
ERP Success Hinges on Effective Data Migration
By Kati Hvidtfeldt July 15, 2025
Three Costly ERP Data Prep Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
April 25, 2025
Streamline your ERP selection process with our cloud-based, modern, data-driven evaluation tool. Simplify business process requirements, accelerate ERP implementation, and gain unbiased, real-time insights for optimal manufacturing and solution fit.
April 25, 2025
Discover the limitations of AI tools in ERP selection through a real-world case study comparing Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central and Finance & Supply Chain Management. Learn why expert analysis is crucial for accurate ERP requirements assessment.
April 25, 2025
Debating if Business Central is the right move for you? The key to making the right decision lies in understanding your business requirements—not just what your ERP system does for you today, but what you truly need from an ERP system now and in the future.
With our latest enhancements to Discover, you can now compare your answers to those of similar busin
April 25, 2025
With our latest enhancements to Discover, you can now compare your answers to those of similar businesses. This means faster data collection, smarter decisions, and a smoother ERP selection process.
Overbuying mfg erp is just as bad as underbuying
April 25, 2025
Which is worse? Underbuying results in relentless and expensive change orders, or overbuying and paying for modules that you don't even need? Avoid falling into either of these traps with a Discover Assessment.
The word erp is coming out of a circle with a light coming out of it.
April 25, 2025
How do you calculate a successful ERP implementation project? We base it on three aspects: on-time, on-budget, and on-spec. Learn the real cost of a manufacturing ERP implementation.
A blurred image of a city with the word erp and icons.
April 25, 2025
Discover simplifies ERP cost estimation by providing a detailed analysis of design and build hours, helping organizations accurately compare the implementation costs of Dynamics Business Central and FSCM to make informed, budget-conscious decisions.