ERP Implementation: The Missing Ingredient in Success

pjoeckel • March 5, 2024

ERP Implementation: The Key Element to Achieving Success.

 I recently found myself engrossed in yet another white paper, this one promising to reveal the secrets of successful ERP software implementation. As I delved into the document penned by respected ERP experts, I asked: Did I gain any new insights? Did I find any valuable takeaways? The answer, unfortunately, was a resounding no.


Like countless others I’ve read, this white paper echoed the same advice circulating in the ERP community for years. It was reminiscent of the numerous “Top XYZ” lists that claim to hold the keys to ERP project success. Yet, ERP implementations fail alarmingly despite the abundance of advice available with a simple Google search.


So, what constitutes an ERP project failure? If a project fails to meet three fundamental criteria for success, it should be classified as a challenged or failed project. These criteria are:


  • On-time delivery
  • On-budget delivery
  • On-spec delivery


With so much expert advice readily available, why do ERP implementations continue to stumble? In my experience, the advice offered is often academic, rehashing the same guidance that has previously led to significant cost and time overruns and failure to deliver the promised functionality.


When I peruse this advice, I find nothing innovative or practical. Generic, oft-repeated academic guidance is abundant, but there is a shortage of helpful tips you can immediately apply to your project to make a meaningful impact.


Even more frustrating is when this unhelpful advice is hidden behind paywalls, requiring you to shell out hundreds or thousands of dollars. And let’s not forget the consulting and implementation firms that charge exorbitant fees only to lead projects to repetitive failures.


Interestingly, I'm met with enthusiastic agreement whenever I highlight these issues in speaking sessions or during consultations with individual teams. It seems everyone has firsthand or secondhand knowledge of how these projects fail. Yet, no one seems willing to challenge the status quo as the same flawed processes are used repeatedly.


In conclusion, the ERP implementation landscape is in dire need of a shake-up. We must move away from regurgitated academic advice and towards practical, actionable strategies that can drive project success. Only then can we hope to improve the success rate of ERP implementations.




Avoid ERP project failure!With a GYDE365-Discover assessment, you'll r eceive an in-depth analysis report pack that includes:


  • Recommended modules based on your company's processes
  • Defined list and analysis of your company's requirements
  • Gap/fit analysis to Dynamics Business Central and FSCM (easily benchmark to non-Microsoft ERP solutions if desired)
  • Implementation project estimates, including timeline, budget, and licensing costs
  • RFP/RFI-ready documents
  • ...and much more!


Contact us today to learn more!

Recent Posts

ERP Data Migration, Data Quality, ERP Implementation, Data Governance, Master Data, ERP Readiness
By Kati Hvidtfeldt July 23, 2026
Learn how to improve ERP data quality, reduce migration risk, decide what data to move, and avoid bringing legacy system problems into a new ERP.
By Kati Hvidtfeldt July 18, 2026
Learn how to choose the right ERP, uncover the hidden cost of disconnected systems, and build a realistic ERP implementation budget before vendor demos.
ERP advisory, ERP consulting, independent ERP advisor, ERP selection, ERP implementation,
By Kati Hvidtfeldt June 4, 2026
HandsFree ERP helps companies reduce ERP implementation risk with independent ERP advisory, data-driven ERP selection, Discover assessments, data health checks, ERP Success Academy, and AI-ready business transformation planning.
Person's legs resting on car window. Sunset over the ocean. Wearing white sneakers.
By Peter Joeckel February 16, 2026
When you run an AI agent, which is an AI designed to take actions like sending emails, browsing files, or accessing databases, you are essentially giving it a set of instructions and the "keys" to your digital tools.
Four blue and gold US Navy Blue Angels jets flying in formation against a clear blue sky, leaving white contrails.
By Kati Hvidtfeldt February 3, 2026
Learn how ERP projects can reach near zero failure by applying aerospace, pharma, and financial services discipline with independent validation and risk governance.
HandsFree logo with a check. A blue shield with a check mark sits on the check. A green dollar sign is on the right.
January 28, 2026
ERP decisions carry financial and organizational risk. HandsFree ERP provides independent guidance to improve decision quality and prevent costly failures.
By Kati Hvidtfeldt January 16, 2026
You Cannot Know What You Don’t Know Unless ERP Delivery Is Your Profession
By Peter Joeckel January 7, 2026
ERP Business Leaders Implications and Opportunities
By Kati Hvidtfeldt January 5, 2026
Lessons from the Front Lines of ERP and Reporting
By Peter Joeckel January 1, 2026
Reducing the Latest Threat to ERP Success!
Show More
ERP Data Migration, Data Quality, ERP Implementation, Data Governance, Master Data, ERP Readiness
By Kati Hvidtfeldt July 23, 2026
Learn how to improve ERP data quality, reduce migration risk, decide what data to move, and avoid bringing legacy system problems into a new ERP.
By Kati Hvidtfeldt July 18, 2026
Learn how to choose the right ERP, uncover the hidden cost of disconnected systems, and build a realistic ERP implementation budget before vendor demos.
ERP advisory, ERP consulting, independent ERP advisor, ERP selection, ERP implementation,
By Kati Hvidtfeldt June 4, 2026
HandsFree ERP helps companies reduce ERP implementation risk with independent ERP advisory, data-driven ERP selection, Discover assessments, data health checks, ERP Success Academy, and AI-ready business transformation planning.
Person's legs resting on car window. Sunset over the ocean. Wearing white sneakers.
By Peter Joeckel February 16, 2026
When you run an AI agent, which is an AI designed to take actions like sending emails, browsing files, or accessing databases, you are essentially giving it a set of instructions and the "keys" to your digital tools.
Four blue and gold US Navy Blue Angels jets flying in formation against a clear blue sky, leaving white contrails.
By Kati Hvidtfeldt February 3, 2026
Learn how ERP projects can reach near zero failure by applying aerospace, pharma, and financial services discipline with independent validation and risk governance.
HandsFree logo with a check. A blue shield with a check mark sits on the check. A green dollar sign is on the right.
January 28, 2026
ERP decisions carry financial and organizational risk. HandsFree ERP provides independent guidance to improve decision quality and prevent costly failures.
By Kati Hvidtfeldt January 16, 2026
You Cannot Know What You Don’t Know Unless ERP Delivery Is Your Profession
By Peter Joeckel January 7, 2026
ERP Business Leaders Implications and Opportunities
By Kati Hvidtfeldt January 5, 2026
Lessons from the Front Lines of ERP and Reporting
By Peter Joeckel January 1, 2026
Reducing the Latest Threat to ERP Success!
Show More